Types of electronic signatures: SES, AES and QES compared
The three types of electronic signatures (SES, AES, QES) compared, what a qualified electronic signature is, and which one fits which contract in the US and EU.
Actualizado el 12 de noviembre de 2026
There are three types of electronic signatures in European law: the simple electronic signature (SES), the advanced electronic signature (AES) and the qualified electronic signature (QES). They differ in how strictly the signer is identified, how easily the signature can be proven and whether it counts as a handwritten signature. US law does not use these levels at all. This article compares the three types, explains what a qualified electronic signature is and how to get one, and shows which signature is common for which contract in the United States, the EU and the UK.
This article is not legal advice. It describes the general legal situation as of October 2026. Individual cases, states and countries can differ.
The three types of electronic signatures under eIDAS
In the EU, the levels are defined in Article 3 of the eIDAS Regulation (EU) No 910/2014, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183. Article 25 says that an electronic signature cannot be denied legal effect or be refused as evidence in court only because it is electronic or does not meet the requirements of a QES. The UK kept the same three levels after Brexit in its retained version of the regulation (UK eIDAS).
Simple electronic signature (SES)
The SES is the base level: data in electronic form that the signer uses to sign. A typed name at the end of an email, a pasted image of a signature or a signature made through a personal email link all count. There are no technical minimum requirements. Most everyday e-signatures are SES.
Advanced electronic signature (AES)
Under Article 26, an AES has to meet four requirements. It is uniquely linked to the signer, it is capable of identifying the signer, it is created with means the signer can keep under their sole control, and it is linked to the document so that any later change can be detected. In practice it usually relies on a certificate tied to a verified identity.
Qualified electronic signature (QES)
A QES is an AES that is also based on a qualified certificate and created with a qualified signature creation device. The certificate is issued by a qualified trust service provider after it has verified the signer's identity. Under Article 25(2), a QES has the same legal effect as a handwritten signature, and a QES from one EU member state is recognized in all others.
SES, AES and QES compared
| SES | AES | QES | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Requirements under eIDAS | none in particular | Art. 26: unique link to the signer, identification, sole control, changes detectable | as AES, plus a qualified certificate and a qualified signature creation device |
| Identity check | not required, often the email address | required, method not fixed | identity verified by a qualified trust service provider |
| Evidential value | assessed freely by the court; depends on the evidence (audit trail, timestamps) | higher, because the person and the integrity are documented | highest; equal to a handwritten signature |
| Replaces a handwritten signature where the law requires one | no | no | yes in the EU, unless electronic form is excluded |
| Typical effort and cost | low, often free or a small fee per document | medium, depends on provider and identity check | higher: one-time identity check plus a fee per signature or a subscription |
The level says something about proof and form, not about whether a contract is valid at all. Most contracts have no form requirement and can be signed with an SES.
Electronic signatures in the United States: ESIGN and UETA
US law takes a different approach. It is technology neutral and has no signature levels. The federal Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN Act, 2000) and the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA), which nearly every state has adopted, say that a signature, contract or record may not be denied legal effect solely because it is in electronic form. New York relies on its own Electronic Signatures and Records Act instead of UETA.
What matters in the US is evidence: that the signer intended to sign, agreed to do business electronically, and that the signature can be attributed to the person and the record kept unchanged. A clear audit trail, timestamps and a tamper-evident PDF do this work, not a certificate level. Consumer transactions need the consumer's consent to electronic records under ESIGN.
ESIGN excludes some documents, among them wills, codicils and testamentary trusts; adoption, divorce and other family law matters; court orders and official court documents; notices of utility shutoffs, foreclosure, eviction or the cancellation of health or life insurance; product recall notices; and most of the Uniform Commercial Code apart from sales and leases of goods. Some states have their own rules for these areas, for example electronic will statutes.
Which signature for which contract?
The table shows the signature that is generally sufficient. It does not replace a review of the individual case; contract clauses, industry rules and state law can be stricter.
| Document | United States | EU (example: Germany) and UK |
|---|---|---|
| NDAs, quotes, purchase orders, sales and service contracts | e-signature (SES) under ESIGN/UETA | SES |
| Move-in and move-out checklists, job completion certificates, delivery notes | SES | SES |
| Employment offer letters and standard employment contracts | SES | generally SES; some countries require written form for fixed-term contracts (Germany: QES or paper) |
| Residential leases | generally SES, state law can add requirements | depends on the country; Germany: leases over one year need written form (QES or paper) |
| Real estate deeds | e-signature with notarization, often remote online notarization, if the county accepts e-recording | usually a notary is required |
| Consumer credit agreements | SES with ESIGN consumer consent | often written form (Germany: QES or paper) |
| Wills, adoption, divorce | excluded from ESIGN, paper or a state e-will statute | paper or notary |
| Deeds in England and Wales | not applicable | e-signature possible, but the witness generally has to be physically present |
What is a qualified electronic signature?
A QES is the electronic equivalent of a handwritten signature in the EU. This is how it works:
- Identity check: a qualified trust service provider verifies your identity once, for example with a national eID card, a video call or in person. Qualified providers are listed in the EU trust lists.
- Certificate: the provider issues a qualified certificate in your name.
- Signing: today usually as a remote signature. The key stays in a secured system of the provider and you confirm each signature with a second factor, such as an app. Signature cards with a reader are the alternative.
- Verification: the signed PDF contains the signature and the certificate. PDF readers and validation services show whether the signature is valid and the document unchanged.
For a contract that requires the electronic form, each party needs its own QES.
How do I get a qualified electronic signature?
Choose a qualified trust service provider listed in the EU trust list, or a signing platform that works with one, complete the identity check and sign. Several large e-signature platforms sell QES as an add-on in the EU. Costs are usually per signature, as packages or as a subscription, and the identity check is often the largest part.
Electronic signatures with Sealed Print
Sealed Print uses the SES. Signers sign through their own email link without an account, typed or drawn. The finished PDF gets a platform seal with timestamps, a certificate of completion with an audit trail, and a verification code with a QR code on every page, which can be checked even on paper. Everyone involved receives the signed PDF by email. Data is stored in the EU (the Netherlands and France). The steps are described in the signatures guide.
The seal makes later changes visible and strengthens the evidence, but the signatures remain SES. They suit contracts without a form requirement in the EU and ordinary e-signature use in the US, for example contracts for signature or a move-in and move-out checklist. They are not suitable for documents that require a QES or paper. The free plan has no monthly fee and bills signatures per use; see pricing.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between SES, AES and QES?
An SES has no particular requirements. An AES is uniquely linked to the signer and makes changes to the document detectable. A QES is additionally based on a qualified certificate issued after an identity check and is equal to a handwritten signature in the EU.
Is DocuSign a qualified electronic signature?
A standard DocuSign envelope is generally a simple or, depending on the setup, an advanced electronic signature. DocuSign also offers QES for the EU through qualified trust services as a separate option. The same applies to most large e-signature platforms: the level depends on the identity check and certificate used, not on the brand.
Is a simple electronic signature legally binding?
Yes, in the US for almost all contracts under ESIGN and UETA, and in the EU for all contracts without a form requirement. How strong it is in a dispute depends on how well it is documented who signed and when, for example through an audit trail, timestamps and a seal.
Do I need a qualified electronic signature in the United States?
Generally no. US law has no QES requirement. A QES can matter when you sign with partners in the EU and the contract falls under a law that requires written form. This article is not legal advice.
What qualifies as an electronic signature?
Under ESIGN, an electronic sound, symbol or process attached to or logically associated with a record and adopted by a person with the intent to sign. Under eIDAS, data in electronic form used by the signer to sign. A typed name, a drawn signature and a click on "Sign" can all qualify.